Charlie Lamb put us ahead on 15 mins as he cut inside then shot inside the near post, but less than 2 minutes later the scores were level as the visitors converted a cross.
With the game very even, we took the lead again on 70 mins after a foul on James Ward saw a penalty given and the defender sent off. Rob Jefferson scored to make it 2-1.
But again we couldn't hold onto the lead as less than 5 mins later we conceded our own penalty that was scored to even the tie.
Then as per the new Durham FA rules the tie went to penalties. The two teams matched each other until the visiting keeper turned our last penalty around the post to send them through.